Heritage Sidelined, Scrutiny Curtailed: The troubling approval of King Alfred

Heritage Sidelined, Scrutiny Curtailed: The troubling approval of King Alfred

After close to six hours at Hove Town Hall on the 29 July, nine Councillors voted (8 – 1) to approve the application for the King Alfred, subject to referral to the Secretary of State. From the pallid visuals submitted by the Case Officer we were informed that the application complied with Policies but acknowledged that the centre would be smaller, with different uses. The aim was to ‘look at a more holistic view of the site which would encourage tourism and regenerate the area. Any harm would be outweighed by significant public benefit including open space, public realm and linkages to the beach park. There would be no significant transport impact; linkages would be enhanced and no neighbours lived immediately adjacent to it. On balance, it is acceptable.’

Some last-minute amendments to the scheme included a proposed 8-lane main pool, a slightly larger teaching pool, reduced leisure pool play, reduced spectator seating, double size wet change, and 150 gym stations instead of 31. However, there appears to be differences between the Officer Report and the Planning Statement in the figures for the gym stations, studios, splash pad, teaching pool, spectator seating and soft play. The main entrance has been relocated to the east side. The café remains extensive.  

The north and north-east elevations might have a parapet to soften the view along the Kingsway.

Much time was taken regarding transport and access. It was like watching a House of Commons debate where a subject takes so long that time runs out to avoid questioning other important issues. However, the questions highlighted the lack of detail about emergency procedures, and delivery and rubbish collection from the site.

It was revealed that the proposed low headroom to the car parking undercroft would rule out vehicles higher than 2.1m, which would exclude large SUVs as well as mini-buses. Coach parking would be difficult too, as drivers would have to park along the A259 or in Hove Street.

The real issue here, of course, is that the site is much smaller, with an abysmal design. Not enough time was given to this. We’re not to worry though as, according to the Head of Placemaking, in such a joyful building the children will be happy splashing about in the pools while the grown-ups enjoy their coffee and cake in the café inspiring healthy and active living. The landscaping will be breathtaking too with planting and seating stretching to the beach – plaza style – with the addition of market stalls, pop-ups and local musicians performing in and around the amphitheatre. What more can we ask for on sunny days?

Image from the amended scheme

The Councillor who voted against the scheme reiterated some of the points highlighted by us in our June newsletter.

She was disappointed that the building would be much smaller than at present for a growing population. A 50m pool would be preferable to enable competitions; the splash pool was too small, and there was not enough for teenagers.

She considered that the front looks like an industrial building and suggested a design to reflect the nearby regency-style buildings. She added that this should have been one application, and not two [this refers to the proposed six residential tower blocks]. £65m is a lot of money for something smaller.

Proposed parapet: Image from the amended scheme

Residents have every right to be concerned about the cost which have already risen from £47m to £65m, suggesting a scheme that may be unstable before it even begins. The projected net income appears optimistic and should be revisited. We have been here before when the business case for the i360 overestimated visitor numbers.

On an equally serious note, we have to mention the hostile treatment towards the Conservation Advisory Group (CAG) representative at the meeting. He was left waiting for almost five hours before being called to speak, but immediately before addressing the committee the Council’s legal officer informed him that he would not be permitted to comment on the amended scheme, the published officer’s report, or the officers’ presentation.

We also question procedural changes affecting CAG’s participation that had not been formally approved or communicated by Officers in advance. The applicant and planning officers were afforded extensive opportunities over several hours to explain and defend the proposals, while CAG’s representative was denied an equivalent opportunity to respond to amendments, officer advice or issues arising during the meeting. No committee member asked him any questions.

We believe these events created an imbalance in the presentation and testing of evidence before the committee. As the Council’s recognised independent heritage advisory body, its role is to assist members in reaching well-informed decisions on matters affecting the historic environment. Restricting that role, or creating the perception that it has been restricted, risks undermining public confidence in the planning process.

For us, the lesson from July’s meeting is stark: when scrutiny is curtailed and heritage voices are sidelined, the city is left with decisions that neither reflect its character nor serve its future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *